MyIdol - American Idol - Thread - Changes for this season sound great

Sign-Up

AMERICAN IDOL FORUMS

MyIdol Forums

Season 8

General American I..

Changes for this season sound great

Post Reply

Page 3 of 4

Prev 1 2 3 4 Next

Changes for this season sound great

11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 6:59PM #21
pizzarocks Posts: 1830	Jan 11, 2009 -- 5:35PM, Scifisam wrote: Jan 11, 2009 -- 5:14PM, pizzarocks wrote: I am not looking forward to the new judge. I mean she seems nice but that means the judges favorites will make it on the show not the people who are good Wait a minute, I'm having trouble understanding your post, could you explain what you mean? Sorry about that. What I am trying to say with a 4th judge some people who are good might not get on the show unless we vote like crazy Kara rocks she puts Simon in his place Mis fortune shows to those who aren't my true friends Stevie wonder fan #9 arianna afsar fan #7 MAC MATES # 23 Grace Notes/Alexis fan #25 Glambert #333 Alli Kat #52 Gokebert #123 DioGuardians #1 GlamKatz #1 Allison is the next American idol Keep Allison on idol vote vote vote
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:06PM #22
Scifisam Posts: 10733	Jan 11, 2009 -- 6:59PM, pizzarocks wrote: Sorry about that. What I am trying to say with a 4th judge some people who are good might not get on the show unless we vote like crazy Wow, I must be extremely dim tonight, I'm still not getting it. How does a 4th judge connect to voting? I'm sorry, I'll just let it go if my incompetence is getting annoying. "We recognize the present is half as pleasant as our nostalgia for the past that we've resented, recast and reinvented, until it's how we meant it" -BNL
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:07PM #23
valeri Posts: 17282	Jan 11, 2009 -- 8:06PM, Scifisam wrote: Wow, I must be extremely dim tonight, I'm still not getting it. How does a 4th judge connect to voting? I'm sorry, I'll just let it go if my incompetence is getting annoying. nope.. not just you. I don't get it either! LOL Giraud Squad #2 David Cook will always be my #1 American Idol Winner.
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:30PM #24
fouru2stitchagain Posts: 2406	I would think that fourth judge would possibly balance out some of the favoritism or unfavoritism we saw last season. Maybe knock Simon's effectiveness on the viewers down a little. To the world you may be one person, but to one person you may be the world!!! Drill team#10...whoo hoo!!! GO Michael! Proud to be FART #15!! Gokey Gang #357 I signed up for Twitter....now how do I Tweet?? RIP Butch, Love you always
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:34PM #25
valeri Posts: 17282	The ONLY thing about a 4th judge is .. what do they do if its 2-2... who breaks the tie? LOL Giraud Squad #2 David Cook will always be my #1 American Idol Winner.
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:35PM #26
Scifisam Posts: 10733	Jan 11, 2009 -- 8:34PM, valeri wrote: The ONLY thing about a 4th judge is .. what do they do if its 2-2... who breaks the tie? LOL Simon does (though it should be Ryan, in my opinion) "We recognize the present is half as pleasant as our nostalgia for the past that we've resented, recast and reinvented, until it's how we meant it" -BNL
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:42PM #27
Kariann1 Posts: 4605	Overall, Ryan has been consistent and a GOOD host. I hope he keeps his sense of humor but doesn't get into too much cross talking with Simon. With 4 judges, there will be less time for filler and fluff!! Anyone remember when Ryan laid next to Taylot Hicks on the floor, laughing it up? My favorite FUNNY moment on the show! What the World needs now is love, sweet love. No, not just for some, but for everyone.
11 months ago :: Jan 11, 2009 - 8:44PM #28
fouru2stitchagain Posts: 2406	Jan 11, 2009 -- 8:42PM, Kariann1 wrote: Overall, Ryan has been consistent and a GOOD host. I hope he keeps his sense of humor but doesn't get into too much cross talking with Simon. With 4 judges, there will be less time for filler and fluff!! Anyone remember when Ryan laid next to Taylot Hicks on the floor, laughing it up? My favorite FUNNY moment on the show! I do remember that. One of my favorites is after Chikeze sang "She's a Woman" and Ryan jumped around with him after..he was so excited..and Ryan just pumped him up more. Very cute!! To the world you may be one person, but to one person you may be the world!!! Drill team#10...whoo hoo!!! GO Michael! Proud to be FART #15!! Gokey Gang #357 I signed up for Twitter....now how do I Tweet?? RIP Butch, Love you always
11 months ago :: Jan 12, 2009 - 8:13AM #29
NYChica1782 Posts: 744	Another classic Ryan moment was when Matt Rogers made the top 12 and he and Ryan chest bumped each other One thing that does confuse me is that if there are 4 judges and 3 wildcard picks, then which judge gets the unlucky decision of having his/her favorite not make the top 12? Roundabouts #2 Glamberts #9 Vontastic #10 Truggernaut #13 Jesse Fan #15 Stevie's Wonders #16 Gokey Gang Member #49 Anoop's Troop #90
11 months ago :: Jan 12, 2009 - 2:26PM #30
coldplayer Posts: 171	Jan 11, 2009 -- 4:02PM, kitkaat wrote: well i guess we will see, but so far the new judge thing is still bothering me. Me too! As annoying as Paula could get, I thought that group of judges is what made the show. I don't like having another one, and I really don't like the part where she demonstrates by singing it. It's just going to take up time. Ugh. The rest sounds ok to me.