MyIdol - American Idol - Thread - Scott Brought Tears to My Eyes

Sign-Up

AMERICAN IDOL FORUMS

MyIdol Forums

Season 8

Scott MacIntyre

Scott Brought Tears to My Eyes

Post Reply

Page 1 of 5

1 2 3 4 5 Next

Scott Brought Tears to My Eyes

8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 1:27AM #1
CalifanSD1 Posts: 2367	When Scott said, "I wanted to show versatility before I go home," I got teary-eyed. He has such a good outlook on life. He realizes he could go home, but wasn't down or upset about it, but kept a positive perspective. I'm sorry the judges had to be so harsh. He definitely didn't deserve it. Kris Allen's debut album in stores November 17! Pre-order on Amazon.com now!! Download Jason Castro's debut single on iTUNES now! Jason's debut album in Stores November 17!! KRIS KREW & ALLENation #100 Gokey Gang #304 Giraud Squad # 465
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 5:11AM #2
Grands1x Posts: 72	I SOOO agree!!! with your tears and your comments. SO hoping Scott will stay another week or two. He deserves to be there!
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 6:41AM #3
beautifulsomehow Posts: 22	I cried during his performance because I loved it, I cried after his performance because the judges were tearing him down, but most of all I cried when Scott talked about going home. I'm just a big, blubbery mess. But I have to say-sorry, Scott, but we're not letting you off the hook. Not now, not ever. You ARE STAYING!!!!!!!! And you're going to win. Scottie #182 No music I had ever heard had made colors and scenes come alive in the way that Scott's piano-playing had. Like little squirrels, the music hopped and danced about the room. The music was alive. -Nicole Girard
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 6:51AM #4
Reidp1 Posts: 432	I'm with all of you - when he said he wanted to show his versatility before he went home, I cried. I was more upset than he was. He really did not deserve the judges' comments. He was fantastic. According to dial i dol, he is third from last, with Kris being in last place. Of course, there is margin for error. I just hope my two hours of voting along with all his other fans was enough to keep him there.
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 7:37AM #5
KSomerset Posts: 3857	I just re-watched Scott's comment, and I didn't think he thought he was going home this week, but that he knew he wasn't going to be the winner of AI (which realistically at least 5 of the contestants have to know that). Not knowing exactly when he would leave, this week or next or the following, I think this was a good week for him to take the risk and let his other side be seen. Next week he can go back to the piano and nail a stellar performance, but he at least got this versatility done. I think Scott played this one very smart, and I applaud him for it. Signature removed due to length
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 2:53PM #6
danni63 Posts: 1358	Apr 8, 2009 -- 6:41AM, beautifulsomehow wrote: I cried during his performance because I loved it, I cried after his performance because the judges were tearing him down, but most of all I cried when Scott talked about going home. I'm just a big, blubbery mess. But I have to say-sorry, Scott, but we're not letting you off the hook. Not now, not ever. You ARE STAYING!!!!!!!! And you're going to win. Here! Here! Beautiful Somehow! I am here in full agreement! I know how you felt! I felt beat up too when the music played and he was not yet finished talking. I just muttered, "my dear Scott." danni63 Wild Angel P.E.R.#14 Scottsland, Scottie #82 Proud to be a Scottie!!! "Scott blessed AI with a lot of class!" Matt Giraud Squad#534
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 2:57PM #7
danni63 Posts: 1358	Apr 8, 2009 -- 7:37AM, KSomerset wrote: I just re-watched Scott's comment, and I didn't think he thought he was going home this week, but that he knew he wasn't going to be the winner of AI (which realistically at least 5 of the contestants have to know that). Not knowing exactly when he would leave, this week or next or the following, I think this was a good week for him to take the risk and let his other side be seen. Next week he can go back to the piano and nail a stellar performance, but he at least got this versatility done. I think Scott played this one very smart, and I applaud him for it. KS, my heart was really broken last night! So sorry I was explosive when I got to the forum this morning. I just hurt for him! I guess he is braver than I. I 'commend you KS; you were just so cool. You shook me out of making a fool of myself! Thanks! danni63 Wild Angel P.E.R.#14 Scottsland, Scottie #82 Proud to be a Scottie!!! "Scott blessed AI with a lot of class!" Matt Giraud Squad#534
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 3:07PM #8
bamaseal Posts: 282	Apr 8, 2009 -- 1:27AM, CalifanSD1 wrote: When Scott said, "I wanted to show versatility before I go home," I got teary-eyed. He has such a good outlook on life. He realizes he could go home, but wasn't down or upset about it, but kept a positive perspective. I'm sorry the judges had to be so harsh. He definitely didn't deserve it. I agree,I was so proud of Scott.He is the kind of role model that I want for my grandchildren...I was really let down with AI but that OK.Scott will survive .He is a winner.
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 7:17PM #9
sherc_golfgirl Posts: 3	OMG!!!!! They kept Lil and Allison and got rid of Scott.....whatever!!!!!!!!!! They are not EVEN in his league! Allison???!!!! I would turn off the radio first! Scott was worth the save.
8 months ago :: Apr 08, 2009 - 7:28PM #10
annietune Posts: 2	Teary-eyed for me to see Scott go. What an inspirational talented guy. He will do well with his career. So sad the judges did not see that they should have kept him.