Wednesday, May 21, 2008, 06:58 AM PST
[
Voting]
If you are coming to my blog to leave a comment that has nothing to do with what I said on my post, then just leave me alone. Doing that just makes you look like you don't know how to read. Don't come here to gloat, or to tell me I'm wrong. I'm not wrong. My opinion is my opinion. Feel free to express yours respectfully, and I'll reciprocate the courtesy.
Okay, now that I got that off my chest, here's what I thought of the show.
I've noticed that some people thought the whole boxing theme was stupid, but I thought it was really cute!

1st round -
They both did a phenomenal job. "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" is one of the best songs ever, from one of the best albums ever (The Joshua Tree... which I own of course). I thought it was a great song choice for David Cook and he was amazing. His voice was flawless. David Archuleta did an incredible job with "Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me." I've thought all season long that he should do that song. They tied for me on this round.
2nd round -
Didn't really care for either song. David Archuleta's song showcased his voice more, David Cook's song was more fun to listen to. I guess for vocals, I'd give Archie the edge this round.
3rd round -
I preferred David Cook's performance of "The World I Know" to David Archuleta's repeat of "Imagine." I do like David Cook's song more - Collective Soul used to be one of my favorite bands. It's a beautiful song and his voice was just really in the zone last night. I cried when he cried after his performance. That was one of the most genuine and raw exhibitions of tears that I've yet seen on the Idol stage. Seeing him so honest and exposed like that in front of millions of people made me want him to win even more.
David Archuleta sang "Imagine" beautifully. But he's not only done it on the Idol stage before, but for other non-Idol performances, too. After the judges gave their comments, and David Cook said that he chose a new song because he felt that the Idol experience should be a "progression", and he didn't want to do something people had already heard, did anyone see Simon wink at him? I think Simon might have actually been setting Cook up for that statement.
So for me, it was about a tie.
I wish the judges couldn't say anything in the finale. And I'm not just saying that because they didn't praise my favorite. It's the same every year. After to listening to rounds 1 and 3, I really didn't know who the judges would give the edge to. I think at least for the finale, people should be able to make up their own mind instead of relying on the judges.
I also wonder if the judges praised David Archuleta so much so the non-voters would come out and support Cook to prove Simon wrong. Simon has before called himself the "kiss of death"... was he playing that up? I'm not denying that Archie deserved the praise, because he did. But it's no secret that Simon wanted Cook to win - he said it on both Jay Leno and Ellen this week. Just a thought.
Last night I voted until 1am, for David Cook.
Although my votes for the two hours or so were basically pointless... and here's why.
My fiance hates David Cook because he's jealous, and so he tricked me into giving him David Archuleta's phone numbers, and then he started speed dialing for him! Mind you, this guy has only watched an actual performance show two other times this season, and both times were when we had company (and the guests also wanted to watch.) He usually makes fun of me for voting.
So anyway, the second that Ruben stopped singing, I grabbed my phone from the charger and began dialing like a maniac. So anyway, he says to me, "What are David Cook's numbers?" So I told him... and then he started dialing and dialing. I thought he was helping out the Word Nerds. But no. I looked at his phone, and I saw 1-866-43657-02 and I was like "Whaaaaaat?" He thought it was so hilarious. Each time I'd get through, it seemed like he'd get through on Archie's line within minutes.
After an hour of voting I was ahead by one vote, 6-5. Yes - we seriously only got in 11 votes combined in the first hour - and we were speed dialing like crazy - with at least 1000 combined attempts. Each time one of us would get through, we'd stick our phone in the other person's ear and laugh. So we had our own little voting competition going on. I was so mad though! And he just kept laughing and laughing. Thankfully he had to charge his phone about halfway through the voting window, and after 11pm I was getting in votes much more speedily. And then I was thrilled when he finally fell asleep!
I tried at least several thousand times to vote. I got that stupid "All servers are busy" message more often than I got a busy signal. I wonder if the Verizon network just has so many people calling in my area. I know people can get through hundreds of times a night, but I've never been able to before. But I did get in at least 100 votes for my Cookie! After the voting was done, I was wide awake, so I was up till 3am posting on the message boards. I am tired.
So to reiterate what I just said (in case you came here just to leave a dumb comment and didn't read my post), they both did great, the judges need to shut up, in my opinion they're tied. May the best David win.
I can't WAIT until tonight!