so sad! you look pretty still i love you !!

Seems like a smart girl, I like her. I didn't necessarily like her song choice but there's no doubt she has amazing chops!

Karen you are so beautiful and a star to be born for sure. You won't be forgotten

I dont no if its my computer or what but there no sound on any of the site and no video on Ryans guffawa....so its hard to rate anything.

Boring....absolutely boring!

I love Karen. I'll buy your stuff! Go produce great music. You have fans! We love you Karen!

Karen, the Hispanic Community is so proud of you.... Eres muy talentosa... no te rindas nunca... recuerda que cuando una puerta se cierra muuuuchas otras se estan abriendo... Naciste para brillar y asi lo haras!!! He seguido tu trayectoria artistica por mucho tiempo, sobretodo en Objetivo Fama y se que tienes una voz hermosa y llegaras muy muy lejos... Manten siempre esa simpatia y humildad que te caracterizan y nuncao dejes de creer en ti porque nosotros tus seguidores siempre te apoyaremos y nunca dejaremos de creer en ti tampoco!!!!

All the haters! Don't waste ur time post in negative stuff. Karen! Rue awesome! Singing in Spanish is a plus! Keep going girl!

Karen, you will go far in life. I'm glad you are not loosing faith-- keep fighting!

You are a credit to your family and yourself, well done!! I love your attitude and positive outlook in life. With a attitude like that you will go places. American idol can be a boost or a stepping stone for your career. Never give up and sing, sing sing!!

Karen, was hoping you would stay, your voice was right on, then couple others, but you would go far.

Karen I was very sad seeing you eliminated. You are an amazing singer and a beautiful person. You represented yourself on stage very well and many of us are very proud of you. I don't regret voting for you! I wish you the best of success in your music career. We love you!!! :)

Casey and paul should have left not karen.She has more talent and can sing twice better than them.Sorry but those two are terrible i don't see where they get they can sing.I voted over and over for karen so did my family.Like adam Lambert he should have been the winner his peronal life should had nothing to with his singing.Karen don't worry like adam you will go futher than the one who wins it.

It is a pity that it does not continue KAREN RODRIGUEZ was the best ....... beautiful mood ...... go ahead, have a beautiful voice, still grown, always as natural as usual, proud to be Peruvian like you

I felt that American didn't get this right. I kinda felt that America couldn't get with her sing in Spanish. And I think I was right. Karen I voted for you and I thought you were wonderful!!!!

Ashton! I want to say this is the girl I wanted to win you know what... I listened to your exit interview and you see I am a great Judge. You are an american idol girl. You Put God First second and last Amen
Continue Looking onto Your Savior who Gave you your awesome gift, And yes make your single or album I will support it... hey look at it this way. God has a perfect plan just for you

I think it was a mistake letting Karen go. I sure hope Marc Anthony or JLo help her get a start. She's beautiful, has a fantastic personality and would truly represent the Latino community AND she can sing!

Miss Karen Rodriguez had more talent then other singers,as she sing so beautiful as she sang in both English & Spanish...this is America and you have rights to speak or sing in any languages! so be a turn on and not a turn down..Latin music. is beautiful and i grew up Latino i learn English and still very proud to still speak my own Spanish!Go Karen you know your a Star in our eyes and community!

I think she has a nice voice. I think she lost it when she sang in spanish. I lot of people disconnected with it. I think she would do well if Idol had a show in south america.

Karen is a beautiful young lady with a great future. Good luck to her.

Does anyone know where I can get a video of Kendra and Paul singing "Blackbird?" I think the two of them together sang that song better then the Beatles did.. I got chill-Bumps..I do not see it here. Would love to see that again... Thanks. Go James~!!!! This Year Rocks!!

i can see your spirit through your eyes Thia! You have a very strong personality! I believe on your pure and genuine heart! A very lovely Filipina woman in in you! God will give you the blessings and a successful singing career! AI is just a first ladder of your life succes!

I am so sad,really disappointed that Pia is voted out i can't believe it SHE IS THE BEST and i thought she's gonna be the season 9 american idol winner

Is America that bad at seeing talent when it's in their face?? Pia, your voice is amazing and your future is just beginning, you get em girl!!

Pia prooved she was not able to win AMERICAN iDOL WHEN SHE PREFORMED HER FAST SONG. yOU MUST BE ABLE TO ENTERTAIN AS WELL. sHE WAS BORING WITH A FAST SONG AND THAT LOST IT FOR HER. SHE PROOVED SHE CAN ONLY DO BALLADS.

americans are nuts for not recognizing talent come on up to canada pia you will get the credit you deserve

See, Steve, Jennifer, and Randy! You shouldn't use that "save" too early! Especially for that Ewok who was rightly sent home!

Pia is great! the show is flawed and I'm not going to watch anymore! the judges and show need to take more control.....ridiculous!

Adelante Pia, tu eres la mejor. La gente q voto cometio una injsuticia y deberian cambiar el sistema de votacion!!!, esta demostrado q la mayoria de votantes no saben de talento, no mas American Idol para mi. Dios te bendiga Pia!!!

It is what it is.... Most of the big names from Idol never won anyway and no matter how they format the voting, someone will always complain about it not being fair. What is fair? I mean, they can't just keep saving everyone or the show would never end. If they really have true talent, they will make it. Follow Pia's example... thousands and thousands of people came to Idol and she made it to the top 9 in the entire United States. I'd say that's quite an accomplishment. Everything happens for a reason and maybe Pia is just destined for greater things. Bottom line though, it really is just a tv show and aren't there more important things going on in the world to focus your energy on? Pia is beautiful, talented, has a wonderful family and had an opportunity of a lifetime... do we REALLY need to feel sorry for her?

Pia was warned about ballads and the need to move around the stage. Her movements were stiff. She got what she deserved and there are others who will be weeded out before the season is over. That's how the show works, so get over it.

Change the way things are done on Idol. Make it a point system ( a combination of America & the judges), the way they do it on Dancing with the Stars. Pia was the best this season & the judges should have saved their SAVE. The tweeners of this country should think about the singing instead of who they think is cute. We all know Pia will have a great career anyway, but she should have won Idol!!!!

Terrible mistake eliminating Pia. She was the BEST vocal talent on the show. My last night to view the show.

Pia! no matter what who wins at the end you are the winner, from all 9 contestant you got the best vocal, you need to do what Daughtry did when he lost, get a band and start recording, he did it, you can do it. believe in yourself. we want to hear more from you, keep singing. Love You!! Jose O.

I'm glad she is gone!!! Go James you are the best on Idol, not Pretty little Pia. Goodbye!!!

AI needs to change their way of voting, it's not fair to the contestants..LIMIT THE VOTES..I could care less how many MILLIONS of votes they get each week

Who cares about ballads!! She had a great voice & should have been the next American Idol. The reason she lost was that the tweeners vote for the cute guys. & wouldn't know a great voice if they heard one, again \, change the way things are done on Idol!

Idol should initiate another save & bring Pia back. They should realize they made a mistake saving Casey, even though he is talented, he is not the singer Pia is.

WIll not be watching AI. Pia should have stayed. Bad move on the judges part saving Casey. Good bye AI, good bye.

America sent the wrong person home. If Stefano was a man he would have stepped down, The American Idiots voted wrong.
The judges shouldn't have wated the one time save so early.

If we are unhappy we can boycott Idol. But how many really will?
If the ratings drop significantly just next then the message will be heard.

But you have to NOT WATCH!

Really, if you think about it, all the other past winners of American Idol, who has really made it and is still around? Whose music do we hear on the radio? Where???s Fantasia, Ruben, Taylor, ummmm???.Kris and Lee. Kelly and Carrie, good job about the only two that have made it, are still around. I only hear of those who did not win American Idol, so chin up Pia. Who ever wins, wins, it???s who can succeed in the business and stay with their fans. Good luck Pia, you will go far.

Producers SAVE Pia she deserves it!!!!

Glad Pia is gone. Now we can watch people who have talent and own the stage and not just stand there. And ones who have more talent than just singing. Musical talent as well. Go Casey, Scotty and James.

I lost it when Chris Daughtry was ousted, then they got it right when David Cook won! But botched it again with Adam Lambert lost...Who won that winner again? This is not American Idol, this is a show failing miserably on keeping the right talent in play!!! You just lost a long time watcher. SImon here I come X-Factor!!!

Goodbye American Idol. And you crazy Producers. What a way to count on a vote. Little teens. Your losing a lot of viewers.
And Simon Cowell didn't do it. You did it all yourselves and your voting system.

America got it so wrong.....They need to do something about it....once and for all make a change!!!!

This is a serious tragedy for American Idol....They need to correct this fast and yes before next week or this will kill their show!!!! Now it will be know as Biggest losers on Idol!!!!! Use your heads......Do the right thing, otherwise it will be your loss....not Pia"S.

Producers need to do something to vote Pia back on. The judges were wrong to use their last vote on what his is name. She is the best I have ever heard on this show, Have another vote. I hope to see her when they tour this summer. I hope producers heard her last night. The voting was wrong, Too many females gone and some of the guys should be gone. Maybe someone should step down and give her another chance.

I am upset Pia got voted off a huge mistake.So beautiful and a great singer.Good luck Pia I know you will make it in the music business.