So sad to see Paul leave,but he'll do well with a career!
I would cast him in a second in a film I'm doing right now!
He's got everything needed for success,Talent,looks and charisma,and he doesn't have to "channel" top sing, he's got a style all of his own!
I wish him all the best of luck!

incasting1 you are so right! amen. LOVE PAULS UNIQUENESS..HE IS ONE OF A KIND!

He should have gone even sooner! Not the right kind of voice for such a show

HALEY needs to go .......sorry

Jacob needs to go, he has a beautiful voice, but doesn't have star quality. he just stands there.

Hey Paul... I am a Canadian fan... was very sad to see you go. You took the news like a real Idol and am so happy to hear that you are going to continue on your path as an artist. It would be so nice if you include Northern Ontario as part of one of your tours. We are a small in numbers ... but have large hearts. All the best to you!

Paul was so perfect Wednesday night. That suit was beautiful.

He seemed to be fighting a cold or allergies though, he didn't have the sparkle he had at the beginning.

jacob is a good singer, but he is not American Idol quality. He always sings the songs that all sound the same.
But i don't like paul either i was waiting for him to be sent home.

I WILL CRY!! I LOVE YOU PAUL!! *ALREADY CRYING*

I am so sad Paul was my favorite!

Paul's elimination shows that America's voting finally got one week right! Paul was the least talented of all the original 13 contestants. He cannot sing; he can't dance; he has no rhythm; he has no coordination; he has no sense of style and dress. All he has is a bit of stage charisma; that's not enough for a true singing/talent competition. He should have been eliminated before the final 24! I'm glad America finally got it right!!!

Jacob is a great singer and probably the one who would win the contest (if he can get by Loren)! Hey, Jacob, if you should win and get a record deal, then please go buy some manhood, Bruh! It could serve you well in your career!

Jacob is a great singer and probably the one who would win the contest (if he can get by Lauren)! However, he's just so dang "girlie"! Hey, Jacob, if you should win and get a record deal, then please go buy some manhood, Bruh! It could serve you well in your career!

pia was my choice as winner this year, too bad the judges had already used their save, i love u casey but pia is awesome, she will still b a star, no doubt!

I hated to see Paul go. His voice is so unique. I think he's great. Pia was my favorite though, and I really hatted to see her go. Her voice is so beautiful. Now I love Scotty. He's my favorite from who is left. He has that deep voice and those sexy eyebrows!! Good job. Jacob is too feminine for my tastes. His voice is wonderful - but I don't like a man that feminine. Lauren is so good. Her voice is wonderful and she she is so beautiful. I think she is awesome.

He WILL go on to a career in show business.He's to unique not to!