Paul's voice reminds me of Rod Stewart. I am anxious to hear more from him.

So cute, reminds me of a young Kenny Loggins, good luck to you!!

Very great voice.

Love,love Paul's voice! Can't wait to hear more from him.

Go Boy look forward to hearing more !!

I hope you read your posts Mr. McDonald! Love your style! PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE sing some Joe Cocker! You remind me so much of him (voice & mannerisms). Can't wait to see more from you. There's HUGE talent this year, but are are a 100% original! Good Luck!

Paul's band page -----> <a href="http://thegrandmagnolias.com/" title="http://thegrandmagnolias.com/" target="_blank">thegrandmagnolias.com/</a>

Hey Paul nice performance last night on idol 03/01/11. I was just thinking about a song that would fit you really nicely. The Bee Gee's "how can you mend a broken heart" I think you can nail this one . Good luck keep up the great work :) . Robert....

I think Paul is a Dark Horse as they say and Happily we are watching him and know he will end up somewhere in the top 10 on Thursday!!!

Paul McDonald - my favorite performance of the week. Picked a perfect song for his voice. Loved it. "Sailing" is another great Rod Stewart song I'd love to hear Paul sing. When is Idol going to start selling individual performances on iTunes? I would have picked up Paul's version of "Maggie May".

Been waiting for you to sing Rod, agree some Cocker would be outrageous. Know you are not originally from N'Vegas, TN but we are rooting for ya here! Come on Paul!

Paul, you remind me of Paolo Nutini (melt). That voice is yummy!!! Would LOVE to hear you sing something by him. I would be *SHOCKED* if you didn't make it to top 2. You are by FAR, the best!

Absolutely love your voice, its so unique and so different from anything I've heard in a while... don't think you're gonna be having to worry about touring in a van anymore lol. Had no idea there was anyone from Huntsville on the show though, I was surprised. I thought I knew everyone from hsv in the music scene, there aren't many of us. You should come down &amp; do a show sometime. Good luck next week and break a leg, you've definitely got something hun!!

Congrats on making the top 10- I had no doubt! Your voice has just the most amazing sound. Your whole style is just IT. I checked out some of your originals- LOVE the "Heartbreak" song &amp; video. Great talent!

I also loved your song choice! I think you should sing Mad World by Gary Jules

Good luck Paul... so cool... can't wait to have your album,,, God Bless...

Paul, so excited to here you are from Huntsville. We are all pulling for you at Rosies. If you ever make it back to town, dinner at Rosies will be on us. Can't wait to here your next performance!

Lets vote Paul the winner this year! He is great and it would be wonderful to change up 'american idol' winners to someone who is really different in sound and keep away from the 'same old, same old'. Everybody vote for Paul!

I LOVE Paul

Who thinks else thinks his voice would be prefect for Loving You Tonight - Andrew Allen? :D

Unique, uplifting, unusual, and a breath of fresh air. Paul's got my vote early in the season.

I simply adore your voice and your movements on stage!!!! All the best from Uruguay!!!!

Id love to hear Paul sing Black Baloon by the Goo Goo Dolls or Beautiful Day by U2.

that Paul is great he has my vote 100 times over....

Why Why whyyyyyy did he get cut? I mean he really should have been there a lot longer than 8th! But, I moved on and I'm darn glad I got to know who he is! All of America and beyond is blessed to have discovered him and can buy his music and follow his band!