We are going to miss you Siobhan! I cant believe you got voted off! Keep up the great singing! Look forward to seeing you sing more in the future! The road for idol may have come to an end, but the road to your singing career has just began! You are going to go along way! This is only the beginning!

I LOVE YOU SIOBHAN. Your singing really touched me and gave me chills every week! You're so beautiful and unique. I hope you continue with your promising career!

Siobhan ... I loved that you did that song. That song meant a lot to me too in my spiritual growth of faith. And you being my favorite singing that song made me so happy. And I really like the way you think. I'll always be your fan. I'm so sad you had to leave at top 6. But in a way, I think it's for the best. My best wishes to you in your future career.

The music world will continue to open its doors to Soibhan. She has an awesome
voice and stage presence. I truly look forward to hearing more from her. This
is what American Idol is about. A unique talent is discovered. Soihban's time
has come to leave the weekly broadcast in order to focus on her true calling !

Donodaris, Atlanta, Georgia

Very Well Said, Siobhan..I really like and love you a lot,, I'm soo depressed that you went home, but apparently this is life but I really want you to become the Next AMERICAN IDOL..Although you're not in the AI Show, I really DO BELIEVE THAT YOU WILL BE A HAVING A HUGE CAREER because everyone knows that You're ONE GREAT BRILLIANT FABULOUS FANTASTIC SINGER....so I know you will be a STAR..it is just a stepping stone for you and the battle is starting right now so STAY REAL and BE YOU and GIVE YOU're Shot in you're performances..we love yah! SIOBHAN IS STILL OUR IDOL THIS SEASON EVER...I just watch because you're there and now It's not worth watching now..I will continue to support you all through out and God Bless in your career..ANIMO SIOBHAN!

Siobhan, you are an amazing talent. The idol show is your jumping off point and you will be very successful. You left the show with grace and dignity! I liked the fact that you are OUTSIDE THE BOX, you are talented, and an amazing and beautiful person. I'll be waiting for your CD.

She is hands down amazing! She takes risks and just gives everything she has. She was robbed. One of the best idols to ever be on this show. She wasn't appreciated by Simon and he got his wish at the end. She will have the last laugh though.

Siobhan. Well spoken. After viewing your diary video, I am even more impressed with your poise, grace, thoughtfulness, intensity, insight, and focus. You have what it takes to make it big in this business, an amazing talent, innovative and creative performances, down to earth self evaluation, a humility about your abilities and an appreciation for other artists, and yet a fearless, risk-taking determination to reach for it all. I am so proud of you and I wish you well. I will be anxiously watching for your first album.

Siobhan, I am happy you made it this far. American Idol is an imperfect process and you should have been in the top three.

It is my belief that Simon obviously wants Crystal Bowersox to win, and that is understandable as she is talented.

You were the only talented threat to Bowersox, and hence Simon just ripped into you every time. That was unfair. I would like to see either Aaron or Mike win as neither one belongs in the top 5; that would really lead to some speculation.

I think Simon is great, too. It is just unfortunate that voting process is so bizarre. There was plenty of talent in the top 24 plus, how it got down to these 5 ... I have no idea!

I agree with all that "laelle" just said. I can only add that there is a real ache in so many hearts that we won't be able to watch you every week now. I will miss that bright smiling face. I am anxious to watch your development as time goes by. I hope you sign a record deal with someone that is worthy of you real soon.

Siobhan, I would like to add one more thing. Back in 1971 as a high school student, my friends liked Led Zeppelin and Crosby, Stills, and Nash...etc. All good groups. I told them that I had heard an album by a guy named Elton John and that I really liked him. They laughed at me. Well, Elton John soon became my favorite and has been ever since. I don't think that anyone could have predicted his success. You my dear, have much of the same qualities as he does. Soon you will be loved by many just like he was and is.

You are the greatest! I voted for you each time. I don't understand how you could be out of the competition, with others who aren't as good as you staying in. You have a future, from being on this television show. American Idol isn't the only way to become a star in music. Just ONE way! Look at all of the famous singers today. They didn't start on American Idol. It is a fun show to watch, but I've been wondering why there are no cash awards to the talent. With millions going to the judges, they haven't thought once that the viewing audience would like to see cash rewards to each talented singer.

David Letterman got it right tonight when he said, "I don't know why they voted you off, and frankly I don't care,...you should be our American Idol"!!

Yeap Siobon Magnus should've been the American Idol and hope to hear some great music from her too.